Mystery Squishies 🎁

Pick the surprise and let the squish choose you. Shop mystery dumplings, jumbo surprises, snack-inspired squishies, and colorful buns packed with personality.
Skip to results list
9 items

Filter

  • Glow Hammy – Mystery Glow-in-the-Dark Squishy
    Sale

    Glow Hammy – Mystery Glow-in-the-Dark Squishy

    Glow Hammy – Mystery Glow-in-the-Dark Squishy
    $8.99 $10.99
  • Mystery Glitter Kitty Squishy – 1 Random Pick
    Sale

    Mystery Glitter Kitty Squishy – 1 Random Pick

    Mystery Glitter Kitty Squishy – 1 Random Pick
    $10.99 $14.99
  • Gimme a Mystery Squish! – Surprise Squishy Toy
    Sale

    Gimme a Mystery Squish! – Surprise Squishy Toy

    Gimme a Mystery Squish! – Surprise Squishy Toy
    $9.99 $12.99
  • 20-Pack Mystery Mini Animal Squishies – Random Cute Squishy Friends
    Sale

    20-Pack Mystery Mini Animal Squishies – Random Cute Squishy Friends

    20-Pack Mystery Mini Animal Squishies – Random Cute Squishy Friends
    $10.99 $14.99
  • Rainbow Mystery Bun Squishy 🌈✨
    Sold out

    Rainbow Mystery Bun Squishy 🌈✨

    Rainbow Mystery Bun Squishy 🌈✨
    $13.99 $19.99
  • Snack Attack Mystery Squishies
    Sale

    Snack Attack Mystery Squishies

    Snack Attack Mystery Squishies
    $9.99 $13.99
  • Jumbo Mystery Squish Surprise
    Sale

    Jumbo Mystery Squish Surprise

    Jumbo Mystery Squish Surprise
    $10.99 $14.99
  • Mystery Squish Surprise
    Sale

    Mystery Squish Surprise

    Mystery Squish Surprise
    $9.99 $14.99
  • Mystery Squishy Dumpling
    Sale

    Mystery Squishy Dumpling

    Mystery Squishy Dumpling
    $8.99 $12.99